缺乏与现有终端铃声集成的终端状态协议
问题概述
文章介绍了用于程序状态的 OSC 7501 协议,但未提及已有的终端铃声(SIGINFO、OSC 3008)以及丰富的状态信息,导致用户对其是否能够替代或补充现有解决方案感到不确定,且对简化通知与细粒度信息的需求未得到明确回应。
痛点标签
- 缺少对现有终端铃声机制的支持或提及
- 需要更细粒度的程序状态信息
- 对简化通知方案的需求
待验证问题
- 是否有用户明确表示希望替换或放弃现有的终端铃声实现?
- 用户是否愿意为此协议付费或寻找商业工具?
- 是否有明确的替代方案(如 OSC 3008)被提及并受到欢迎?
证据
原话 · @Anonymous
The BSDs have had a version of this for many, many years. If you hit ^T on the terminal, you deliver a SIGINFO to the application you're waiting for. By default, you get the program name, what its blocked on, and info about real/user/sys time and memory use.Starting an emacs window in the fg:% emacs ^T emacs-31.1 64938 [select] 2.89r 0.75u 0.06s 6% 122404k
原话 · @Anonymous
The problem `OSC 7501` addresses would slot almost perfectly into [UAPI.15 OSC 3008](https://uapi-group.org/specifications/specs/osc_context/#met...).It's already implemented by `systemd` and is available in Ubuntu 26.04.I'd rather see `OSC 3008` being extended.
原话 · @Anonymous
I like the idea, but we already have the terminal bell. In my setup, when an agent is done or needs something, it emits a bell. Based on config, this results in a desktop notification if I’m not in the terminal, or a toast from my multiplexer if I’m in the terminal. The terminal pane gets a colored “bell” icon in its title that is cleared when I attach to it.The total lack of mention of the terminal bell in the article is weird. I think it needs to be addressed for the protocol to be taken seriously. More granular info sounds nice, but also nice is the simplicity of the bell.
原话 · @Anonymous
I've been using a poor mans version of this for decades.My iTerm2 is configured to show activity, new-output and visual bell in the tab. On Linux I have an approximation for WezTerm.I have a bell command that I can use in a pipeline or sequence to produce the bell on events I'm interested in. Trivial case is when a program finishes.I have a fancy alias that can be used in a shell command sequence and which produces different sounds depending on the exit status of the preceding command in addition to sending the terminal bell.
免责声明:本卡片由 AI 从社区讨论中提炼,属于「痛点证据」,是需求分析与验证的起点,不等同于「已验证的市场需求」。AI 存在分析局限,关键决策前请打开上方原始讨论人工复核。